About $9 billion in bitcoin, taken from cryptocurrency exchange Bitfinex in a 2016 hacking incident, must be returned to the exchange, the US Department of Justice (DOJ) said.
This claim arises from a legal document provided by the Department of Justice, which indicated that there are no identifiable victims in this specific case within the current legal structure.
Bitfinex May Recover Stolen Bitcoin
the Court documentswhich was filed on Tuesday, clarifies that recoveries of the stolen bitcoin — specifically 94,643 bitcoin, along with amounts from various hard forks — must be returned to Bitfinex.
The Justice Department said that under the Mandatory Victim Restitution Act (MVRA), there is no legal basis for classifying Bitfinex or its account holders as victims of the specific crimes for which the defendants were convicted.
The defendants, Elijah Lichtenstein and Heather Morgan, were convicted of a money laundering conspiracy, but more importantly, were not charged with the initial hack that led to the theft of bitcoin.
According to the Department of Justice, their subsequent actions did not directly cause the losses incurred by Bitfinex. The statutory definition of “victim” as set out in the MVRA requires immediate and proximate harm resulting from the commission of a specific crime, which it is argued does not apply in this case.
Legal challenges in recovering crypto assets
The Justice Department’s filing confirms that although mandatory restitution cannot be ordered under the current convictions, the court retains the power to award voluntary restitution.
This means that as part of the plea agreements, the defendants agreed to return the stolen assets to Bitfinex. The recovery order proposed by the Department of Justice will include all funds recovered from the Bitfinex Hack Wallet.
While this ruling represents a potential financial windfall for Bitfinex, it also opens the door to further legal complications. The government is currently conducting an additional third-party forfeiture to address other seized assets associated with the defendants’ money laundering activities.
These additional assets, which were involved in complex laundering schemes, may not be classified as specific property lost by Bitfinex and its account holders.
The 2016 Bitfinex hack, one of the largest in cryptocurrency history, had lasting repercussions, leading to ongoing discussions about regulatory standards and compensation for victims in the digital asset space.
As this situation develops, the parties involved in the case will focus on the court’s final ruling on the return of the seized bitcoin, its impact on the future of cryptocurrency regulation, and recovery methods for future cases.
The Justice Department’s efforts aim not only to address the financial losses incurred by Bitfinex, but also to clarify the legal ramifications related to the theft of digital assets.
At the time of writing, Bitcoin has managed to regain its upward momentum with a 4% rise over the past 24 hours towards the $99,100 level.
Featured image of DALL-E, chart from TradingView.com
Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.