Darker Than a Dark Pool? Welcome to Wall Street’s ‘Private Rooms’

(Bloomberg) – The famous dark swimming pools in Wall Street became darker.

Most of them read from Bloomberg

After a decade, it was immersed by a controversy crowned with multiple enforcement procedures and the cabin of organizations, which promotes outlaw trading platforms a way to buy and sell stocks that are more mysterious.

They offer what is called the private rooms, and the walled places that take the basic benefit of a dark group – the ability to hide large stock deals so as not to affect prices – and add uniqueness, and determine who can participate exactly in any trade.

They were created inside the dark swimming pools themselves, and the rooms are independent of each other, and each of them is not visible to anyone who has not been invited, raising questions about the transparency of the market and fragmentation. But with more than half of all all shares trading in the United States that now happens away from public stock exchanges, they are required from companies that yearn to choose those who do their business, and often to help them implement individual requests more efficiently.

“It is like shopping when you know exactly the element you want, and who you buy or sell from him, instead of going to Walmart on Black Friday,” says David Kanizo, head of electronic trading at Raymond James and Partners. “You control the conditions of participation.”

At the present time, it is impossible to determine the number of private rooms, or the amount of activity through which it moves. Companies that run alternative trading systems, or ATS – the official term for dark complexes – say it is a minority of their sizes at the present time, because growth in demand is a relatively new phenomenon.

But they are watching a quick adoption by all intermediary experts and market makers to hedge funds and asset directors, to the point that the sizes of private rooms in one of the main ATS-Stalford, Intelligence in Contecticut-now the total trading activity in nine dark competitors.

Dark gatherings are called because the deals that they deal with talk out of the “lit” public exchange. This helps prevent the leakage of demand details to the broader market and to cause negative price movements before implementing them. But there is still a negative side: an open gathering for anyone, and the companies inside it never know who is its spectrum in any trade. Special rooms can be more secret.

“It comes to control, what liquidity that mediator wants to interact with to achieve better implementation quality,” says Roman Genes, CEO of Intervative Execution, the parent company of Intelligentcross.

There are countless reasons that users may choose private rooms. Take Castleoak Securities case, run by minority in New York. The company wants to trade with similar companies to think, so a special room is used by the ATS OneCronos operator.

“It comes to controlling, what liquidity that the broker wants to interact with.”

Carlos Kabana, head of sales of stock and trading at Castleoak, calls the room “collects diversity”, because all participants are run by minorities. While in this case, Castleoak does not know specifically who is on the other side of every trade, he knows that he will be one of about 10 parties to meet some eligibility standards related to the goals of ownership and investment.

“Think about it as an apartment that hosts a party, and there is one purpose for the party with the guests who are only invited,” says Kabana.

Thanks to the growing Castleoak of the diversity group, Onechronos is now the third most used trading place, behind the New York Stock Exchange for Securities only and Nasdak, says Cabana.

Excellence implementation

Special rooms are known by a large number of other names including hosted swimming pools, restricted access rooms, ATS bathrooms, and allocated opposite end groups. They gain popularity in the huge and advanced modern market as a way to help companies avoid losing against players who may be able to move faster or who have access to extreme information.

For example, many brokers and market makers are keen to take the other side of the retailer orders. It is unlikely that these small and less volatile trades will affect prices – so the market maker will not see a negative step that occurs a moment that agrees to fill the demand, as it may happen with another type of opposite party.

High frequency traders who love working with Robinhood

Mediators who take orders to private rooms usually expect to fill the matter at the mid -giving point and its width, or NBO (assuming that the room base has been prepared in this way, which is usually the case). If the arrangement is not filled for some reason in the room at the center point, it can move to the broader ATS where other multi -competitive parties can fill it. If the mediator has bad experiences with a private room, they can change to the other in the future, and avoid those opposite parties.

“The problem we have is, how can we determine good liquidity against bad liquidity?” JATIN SURYAWASHI, the global head of the quantum strategy at Jefferies, says, who is estimated that 15 out of 100 shares are carried out by the company's algorithms are currently moving across a room. “When using special rooms, you can specify the priorities of those you want to interact with.”

The growth of private rooms is accelerated amid the deportation of stock trading away from public stock exchanges, and while their use became more common. They appeared at the level of ATS 18 years ago. The level began by allowing companies to match their own orders, in what is known as assimilation. This expanded to other forms of retail, including bilateral and multilateral agreements, where one of the parties agrees to trade with another, or multiple parties agree to interact with each other only, within the same ATS.

After requests from its clients, Intelligentcross began to submit its copy of the private rooms about a year and a half ago, and Onechronos joined the party last year.

Special rooms generally do not need large banks or brokers who have the resources needed to create their ATS or the so -called single birth platforms. This is another breed from the place of trading outside the exchange where the operator is always the opposite party for any trade.

But for the smaller players, it is very expensive and exhausted to build and manage ATS or SDP, meet the related regulatory reports requirements and prepare the necessary connections. The arrangement of a special room in ATS is a solution.

“There are many factors that make the company want to use external sources of this activity instead of keeping it at home,” says Steve Millie, CEO of Kezar Markets, and the father's father. He says: “It may be a cost, or a load that they should not necessarily take over if we can build it, then expand its scope,” using the current network, he says. “We reduce the entry barrier.”

In Intelligentcross, the majority of the rooms currently presented are institutional mediators who do not have the ability to conduct similar activities internally. Jefferies is trading in a private room provided by the company as it interacts with seven other brokers who do not have their ATS, but they have institutional orders, according to Sorwanshi.

“This is always created at the request of one of the subscribers, a host that invites others to be guests in their book,” says Genes in the necessary implementation.

Dark detection

Not all ATS rush to embrace private rooms. New York -based Purestream offers “swimming pools” that works like rooms, but it is revealed to all subscribers if created, and anyone can join. In essence, the room is open to all.

So far, no one has asked to create a Purestream pool, so there is no zero volume in the so -called subtitle, according to CEO Armando Diaz. He says that providing a private room that is not open to all subscribers raises questions about the list. He says: “The more the host controls the room, the more running ATS, and this opens the organizational risks,” he says.

Perhaps the biggest criticism of the private rooms is that they create fake liquidity, because the transactions that occur inside the room are simply assembled with the total activity that her dark father reported. This creates a misleading image of anyone trying to measure the depth of the market, given that the reported trading sizes include an activity that is not available outside the room.

ATS trading places, which are supervised by the Securities and Exchange Commission, which strengthened in 2018, were organized by their supervision on these places by imposing new disclosure requirements. Each dark gathering must now provide a model, ATS-N, which provides an overview of trading mechanisms specified on its basic system.

These models available to the public are included in different details, including whether the private rooms are available. But they do not say how many of the existence or in it, the varying language and the levels of disclosure used means that it may be difficult at times to determine whether ATS hosts any rooms.

“There are no rules to force ATS to break the identity or size of the single rooms,” written by Larry, the head of the market structure at Bloomberg Intelligence, wrote in May. The organizational authority in the financial industry “is doing a good job in the ATS reports on the basis of post -implementation. However, there are no rules to help analysts or users looking to break the percentage of the ATS size that was implemented in the open group against the private room, or the folder implemented using retail strategies.”

“It comes to controlling, what liquidity that the broker wants to interact with.”

Dark gatherings are not strangers of transparency fears. The extensive media coverage and organizational scrutiny about a decade have sparked a decade ago, amid speculation that they gave high-frequency companies advantages against other investors-which partially prompted the book of the Books of Books the best-selling books.

Representatives of the Finra and SEC refused to comment.

“Growth mode”

For its users, the private rooms are a useful tool, but they are still one of a group. The hosted gatherings represent a percentage of numbers of total intelligence sizes at the present time-at a rate of about 5.4 % last year-because they are very new, according to Ginis. “The brokers will take some time to improve this,” he says.

The CEO of Onechronos Capital Markets, Vlad Khandros, says that its rooms are less than 5 % of the size nowadays as “newer for us, so he is still in growth.” But the demand is strong. “We have seen an increasing interest from both retail and institutional mediators,” says Khandros. “Focus on the quality of implementation will continue to grow.”

The level refused to disclose the number of rooms in which you work or the amount of activity that occurs in it, as Miley says that the absence of standards at the level of industry to classify the rooms means that it may be “misleading to estimate.”

Mark Gurliacci, Senior Vice President and senior traders at Allianesbenstein, believes that up to 75 % of the company's activity is now outside education, including in private rooms. While the latter is a small slice of its circulation at the present time, he believes that it is scheduled to grow.

“Many companies are creating private rooms these days,” says Gurliacci, who used to work on the New York Stock Exchange. “It is innovative, and here to stay. There is something more happening than most people know.”

-With the help of Lydia Bewed.

Most of them read from Bloomberg Business Week

© 2025 Bloomberg LP